Aaron C.Berkowitz, Brett E. Berkowitz and Trevor B. Berkowitz v. Republic of Costa Rica (ICSID Case No. UNCT/13/2)
- Claimants' Appendices
- 1 Appendices to the Notice of Arbitration
- Appendix A Nationality
- Appendix B Corporate
- 1 Keeping Track
- 2 Grande Beach
- B.11 EnSp.pdf
- B.12 EnSp.pdf
- B.13 EnSp.pdf
- B.14 EnSp.pdf
- B.15 En.pdf
- B.16 EnSp.pdf
- B.17 EnSp.pdf
- B.18 EnSp.pdf
- B.19 EnSp.pdf
- B.20 EnSp.pdf
- B.21 EnSp.pdf
- B.22 En.pdf
- B.23 En.pdf
- B.24 EnSp.pdf
- B.25 EnSp.pdf
- B.26 EnSp.pdf
- B.27 EnSp.pdf
- B.28 EnSp.pdf
- B.29 EnSp.pdf
- B.30 En.pdf
- B.31 EnSp.pdf
- B.32 EnSp.pdf
- B.33 Sp.pdf
- B.34 EnSp.pdf
- 3 Windows of the Blue Sky
- 4 Copher Group
- 5 Copher Holsten
- 6 Trust
- 7 Berkowitz
- 8 Gremillion
- B.1 En.pdf
- B.2 En.pdf
- Appendix C Arbitration
- Appendix D Arbitration
- Appendix E Arbitration
- E.1 130412 Spence Intl Investments Waiver EnSp.pdf
- E.2 130412 Bob Spence Waiver EnSp.pdf
- E.3 130415 Joseph Holsten Waiver EnSp.pdf
- E.4 130418 Brenda Copher Waiver EnSp.pdf
- E.5 130417 Ronald Copher Waiver EnSp.pdf
- E.6 130417 Brett Berkowitz Waiver EnSp.pdf
- E.7 130417 Trevor Berkowitz Waiver EnSp.pdf
- E.8 130417 Aaron Berkowitz Waiver EnSp.pdf
- E.9 130414 Gremillion Waiver EnSp.pdf
- 2 Appendices to the Memorial on the Merits
- 3 Appendices to the Reply on the Merits
- 4 Appendices to the Rejoinder on Jurisdiction
- 1 Appendices to the Notice of Arbitration
- Claimants' Exhibits
- C-0118 Negotiations 2008-2009
- 081006 MINAE email Sp.pdf
- 081006 MINAE email att1 03-10-08 PROTECCION DE LA TORTUGA BAULA.pdf
- 081006 MINAE email att2 03-10-08 Estimados amigos y.pdf
- 081007 MINAE email Sp.pdf
- 081007 MINAE email att 07-10-08 16915SustitivoMINAET.pdf
- 081010 MINAE email Sp.pdf
- 081010 MINAE email att 10-11-08 Analisis comparativo de propuesta de Leyes.pdf
- 081111 MINAE email Sp.pdf
- 081111 MINAE email att1 10-11-08 Analisis comparativo de propuesta de Leyes.pdf
- 081111 MINAE email att2 11-11-08 Baulas.pdf
- 081113 MINAE email Sp.pdf
- 081113 MINAE email att1 10-11-08 Analisis comparativo de propuesta de Leyes.pdf
- 081113 MINAE email att2 11-11-08 Baulas.pdf
- 090211 MINAE email Sp.pdf
- 090226 ACT email Sp.pdf
- 090226 ACT email att1 BAULAS_PROYECTO_LEY_REFUGIO_Y_PARQUE,_26_02_2009 corr.pdf
- 090226 ACT email att2 BAULAS_PROYECTO_LEY_REFUGIO_Y_PARQUE 26_02_2009.pdf
- 090227 ACT email Sp.pdf
- 090227 ACT email att baulas_propuesto-uv 27 febr.pdf
- 100208 Oficio DM-149-2010 MINAE Remision del proyecto de ley Sp.pdf
- C-0119 Baulas Proyecto
- C-1 Legal
- C-0001a DRCAFTA Chapter 10 EnSp.pdf
- C-0001b 910709 Decree 20518-MIRENEM (Decreto 20518-MINEREM) EnSp.pdf
- C-0001c 950608 Law No. 7495 - the “Expropriation Law” (Ley 7495) EnSp.pdf
- C-0001d 060622 Law No. 8508 - the Administrative Contentious Procedural Code modifying Law No. 7495 (Ley 8505) EnSp.pdf
- C-0001e 950710 Law No. 7524 - the “1995 Park Law” (Ley 7524) EnSp.pdf
- C-0001f 050830 Resolution 2238 2005 SETENA (Resolucion 2238 2005 SETENA) EnSp.pdf
- C-0001g 051223 Lt from the Attorney General to the Minister (Carta de Procurador a Ministro) EnSp.pdf
- C-0001h 080523 Constitutional chamber of the SCJ (Decision Sala Constitucional CSJ) EnSp.pdf
- C-0001i 080527 Constitutional Chamber of the SCJ (Decision Sala Constitucional CSJ) EnSp.pdf
- C-0001j 081216 Constitutional Chamber of the SCJ (Decision Sala Constitucional CSJ) EnSp.pdf
- C-0001k 000000 Art 45 Costa Rica Constitution EnSp.pdf
- C-0001l 000000 File 11,202 Legislative Assemble discussions Bill of Law 7524 EnSp.pdf
- C-0001m 440704 Law 59 Law Creating the National Geographic Institute (IGN) Sp.pdf
- C-0001n 770824 Law 6084 Law on National Park Service EnSp.pdf
- C-0001o 820927 Law 6815 related to the Attorney General EnSp.pdf
- C-0001p 900628 Law 7174 Integral Reform to the Forestry Law No 4465 dated 691125 EnSp.pdf
- C-0001q 950410 Environment Law 7554 dated 4 October 1995 EnSp.pdf
- C-0001r 950607 Mts Debate Legislative Assembly re Bill creating Park file 11202 En.pdf
- C-0001r 950607 Mts Debate Legislative Assembly re Bill creating Park file 11202 Sp.pdf
- C-0001s 951027 Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice (Decision Sala Constitucional CSJ) No. 5894-95 EnSp.pdf
- C-0001t 040210 Report by the Attorney General re interpret art 1 Law 7524 En.pdf
- C-0001t 040210 Report by the Attorney General re interpret art 1 Law 7524 Sp LEGAL.pdf
- C-0001u 050628 CR Supreme Court CC Decision - Res. No. 2005-08238 EnSp.pdf
- C-10 V46 CopherHolsten
- C-0010a LOT V46 130108 Land registry drawing (Plano catastro) EnSp.pdf
- C-0010b1 LOT V46 130219 Certification of property RONCO (Certificacion de propiedad RONCO) EnSp.pdf
- C-0010b2 LOT V46 130219 Certification of property JOECO (Certificacion de propiedad JOECO) EnSp.pdf
- C-0010c LOT V46 071009 Decree of public interest (Decreto de interes publico) EnSp.pdf
- C-0010d LOT V46 080917 Administrative Appraisal (Avaluo Administrativo) EnSp.pdf
- C-0010d1 LOT V46 090121 Objection to Administrative Appraisal EnSp.pdf
- C-11 V47 CopherHolsten
- C-0011a LOT V47 130108 Land registry drawing (Plano catastro) EnSp.pdf
- C-0011b1 LOT V47 130219 Certification of property RONCO (Certificacion de propiedad RONCO) EnSp.pdf
- C-0011b2 LOT V47 130219 Certification of property JOECO (Certificacion de propiedad JOECO) EnSp.pdf
- C-0011c LOT V47 071009 Decree of public interest (Decreto interes publico) EnSp.pdf
- C-0011d LOT V47 080917 Administrative Appraisal (Avaluo Administrativo) EnSp.pdf
- C-0011d1 LOT V47 090121 Copher- Obj. to the Adm. Appraisal EnSp.pdf
- C-12 V59 Spence Grande Beach Hold
- C-13 V61A Spence Grande Beach Hold
- C-14 V61B Spence Grande Beach Hold
- C-15 V61C Spence Grande Beach Hold
- C-16 A40 Spence Grande Beach Hold
- C-0016a LOT A40 130108 Land registry drawing (Plano catastro) EnSp.pdf
- C-0016b LOT A40 130219 Certification of property (Certificacion de Propiedad) EnSp.pdf
- C-0016c LOT A40 060330 Decree of public interest (Decreto de interes publico) EnSp.pdf
- C-0016d LOT A40 060922 Administrative Appraisal (Avaluo Administrativo) EnSp.pdf
- C-0016d1 LOT A40 070215 Objection to Administrative Appraisal EnSp.pdf
- C-0016e LOT A40 070412 Decree of expropiation (Decreto de expropiacion) EnSp.pdf
- C-0016f LOT A40 070417 Initiation judicial proceedings (Interposicion Demanda) EnSp.pdf
- C-0016f1 LOT A40 080314 Act of Dispossession Sp.pdf
- C-0016f2 LOT A40 080724 First Judicial Appraisal EnSp.pdf
- C-0016f3 LOT A40 091211 Second Judicial Appraisal EnSp.pdf
- C-0016g LOT A40 101224 Judgment (Sentencia) EnSp.pdf
- C-0016h LOT A40 110721 Appeal Judgment (Sentencia Apelacion) EnSp.pdf
- C-0016h1 LOT A40 110217 Appeal Submission EnSp.pdf
- C-0016i LOT A40 120127 121121 Resolutions ordering payment EnSp.pdf
- C-0016j LOT A40 140115 Documents regarding interests Sp.pdf
- C-17 A39 Spence Grande Beach Hold
- C-18 C96 Spence Grande Beach Hold
- C-19 C71 Spence Grande Beach Hold
- C-2 Reference
- C-0002a Map identifying location for each lot.pdf
- C-0002b Bob F Spence Corporate Structure.pdf
- C-0002c Spence Co GBH Corporate Structure.pdf
- C-0002d Spence Co SPG Corporate Structure.pdf
- C-0002e Map identifying location for each lot.pdf
- C-0002f Extract from C-113.pdf
- C-0002g Figure 2 of Claimants' Memorial on the Merits.pdf
- C-0002h First Figure 3 of Claimants' Memorial on the Merits.pdf
- C-0002i Second Figure 3 of Claimants' Memorial on the Merits.pdf
- C-0002j Figure 4 of Claimants' Memorial on the Merits.pdf
- C-0002k Appendix 1 of Claimants' Reply Memorial.pdf
- C-0002l Revised Appendix 2 of Claimants' Rejoinder on Jurisdiction.pdf
- C-0002m Appendix 3 of Claimants' Reply Memorial.pdf
- C-0002n Appendix 1 of Claimants' Rejoinder on Jurisdiction.pdf
- C-0002o Hierarchy chart of MINAE.pdf
- C-20 SPG1
- C-0020a LOT SPG1 130108 Land registry drawing (Plano catastro) EnSp.pdf
- C-0020b LOT SPG1 130219 Certification of property (Certificacion de propiedad) EnSp.pdf
- C-0020c LOT SPG1 070417 Decree of public interest (Decreto de interes publico) EnSp.pdf
- C-0020d LOT SPG1 070622 Administrative Appraisal (Avaluo Administrativo) EnSp.pdf
- C-0020d1 LOT SPG1 070904 Objection to Administrative Appraisal EnSp.pdf
- C-0020e LOT SPG1 080311 Decree of expropiation (Decreto de expropiacion) EnSp.pdf
- C-0020f LOT SPG1 080411 Initiation judicial proceedings (Interposicion Demanda) EnSp.pdf
- C-0020f1 LOT SPG1 081209 Act of Dispossession Sp.pdf
- C-0020f2 LOT SPG1 080613 First Judicial Appraisal (Primer Avaluo Judicial) Sp.pdf
- C-0020f3 LOT SPG1 100209 Second Judicial Appraisal Sp.pdf
- C-0020g1 LOT SPG1 130226 Judgment of first instance (Sentencia primera instancia) EnSp.pdf
- C-0020g2 LOT SPG1 130510 Resolution accepting judgement EnSp.pdf
- C-0020h LOT SPG1 130510 Resolution accepting and 130522 Additional evidence in support of Appeal EnSp.pdf
- C-0020i LOT SPG1 130114 Payments made to Keeping Track by Government (Pago del Estado a Keeping Track) EnSp.pdf
- C-21 SPG2
- C-0021a LOT SPG2 130108 Land registry drawing (Plano catastro) EnSp.pdf
- C-0021b LOT SPG 2 130220 Certification of property (Certificacion de propiedad) EnSp.pdf
- C-0021c LOT SPG2 070417 Decree of public interest (Decreto de interes publico) EnSp.pdf
- C-0021d LOT SPG2 070621 Administrative Appraisal (Avaluo Administrativo) EnSp.pdf
- C-0021e LOT SPG2 080311 Decree of expropriation (Decreto de expropiacion) EnSp.pdf
- C-0021f LOT SPG2 080411 Initiation judicial proceedings (Interposicion Demanda) EnSp.pdf
- C-0021f1 LOT SPG2 081209 Act of Dispossession Sp.pdf
- C-0021f2 LOT SPG2 080627 First Judicial Appraisal (Primer Avaluo Judicial) Sp.pdf
- C-0021f3 LOT SPG2 100728 Second Judicial Appraisal Sp.pdf
- C-0021g LOT SPG2 120229 Judgment (Sentencia) EnSp.pdf
- C-0021h LOT SPG2 121214 Appeal Judgment (Apelacion) EnSp.pdf
- C-0021i LOT SPG2 140610 Resolution regarding payment Sp.pdf
- C-0021j LOT SPG2 140909 Documents regarding interests Sp.pdf
- C-0021j-1 SPG2 131216 - 141209 Documents regarding interests Sp.pdf
- C-22 SPG3
- C-23 B1 Berkowitz
- C-0023a LOT B1 130108 Land registry drawing (Plano catastro) EnSp.pdf
- C-0023b LOT B1 130219 Certification of property (Certificacion de propiedad) EnSp.pdf
- C-0023c LOT B1 051201 Decree of public interest (Decreto de interes publico) EnSp.pdf
- C-0023d LOT B1 060922 Administrative Appraisal (Avaluo Administrativo) EnSp.pdf
- C-0023d1 LOT B1 061115 Objection to the Administrative Appraisal Sp.pdf
- C-0023e LOT B1 061127 Decree of expropriation (Decreto de expropiacion) EnSp.pdf
- C-0023f LOT B1 061201 Initiation judicial proceedings (Interposicion Demanda) EnSp.pdf
- C-0023f1 LOT B1 080312 Act of Dispossession Sp.pdf
- C-0023f2 LOT B1 070306 First Judicial Appraisal (Primer Avaluo Judicial) EnSp.pdf
- C-0023f3 LOT B1 091105 Second Judicial Appraisal (Segundo Avaluo Judicial) EnSp.pdf
- C-24 B3 Berkowitz
- C-0024a LOT B3 130108 Land registry drawing (Plano catastro) EnSp.pdf
- C-0024b LOT B3 130219 Certification of property (Certificacion de propiedad) EnSp.pdf
- C-0024c LOT B3 051201 Decree of public interest (Decreto de interes publico) EnSp.pdf
- C-0024d LOT B3 060922 Administrative Appraisal (Avaluo Administrativo) EnSp.pdf
- C-0024d1 Lot B3 061115 Objection to Administrative Appraisal Sp.pdf
- C-0024e LOT B3 061127 Decree of expropriation (Decreto de expropiacion) EnSp.pdf
- C-0024f LOT B3 061201 Initiation judicial proceedings (Interposicion Demanda) EnSp.pdf
- C-0024f1 LOT B3 080313 Act of Dispossession Sp.pdf
- C-0024f2 LOT B3 070913 First Judicial Appraisal (Primer avaluo Judicial) Sp.pdf
- C-0024g1 LOT B3 130207 Judgment (Sentencia) EnSp.pdf
- C-0024g2 LOT B3 130221 Judgment Correction of Errors (Sentencia con correccion de errores) EnSp.pdf
- C-0024h LOT B3 130226 131007 131115 Appeal Documents EnSp.pdf
- C-0024i LOT B3 130621 130715 130910 Deposit Resolutions EnSp.pdf
- C-0024i-1 LOT B3 140612 140814 B Resolucion of Payment and Bank Receipts Sp.pdf
- C-0024i-2 LOT B3 141118 141216 Resolution and receipt regarding payment Sp.pdf
- C-0024j LOT B3 140828 Documents regarding interests Sp.pdf
- C-25 B5 Berkowitz
- C-0025a LOT B5 130108 Land registry drawing (Plano catastro) EnSp.pdf
- C-0025b LOT B5 130219 Certification of property (Certificacion de propiedad) EnSp.pdf
- C-0025c LOT B5 051201 Decree of public interest (Decreto de interes publico) EnSp.pdf
- C-0025d LOT B5 060922 Administrative Appraisal (Avaluo Administrativo) EnSp.pdf
- C-0025d1 Lot B5 061115 Objection to Administrative Appraisal Sp.pdf
- C-0025e LOT B5 061127 Decree of expropriation (Decreto de expropiacion) EnSp.pdf
- C-0025f LOT B5 061201 Initiation judicial proceedings (Interposicion Demanda) EnSp.pdf
- C-0025f1 LOT B5 080313 Act of Dispossession Sp.pdf
- C-0025f2 LOT B5 100315 First Judicial Appraisal (Primer avaluo Judicial) EnSp.pdf
- C-0025f3 LOT B5 130500 Second Judicial Appraisal Sp.pdf
- C-26 B6 Berkowitz
- C-0026a LOT B6 130108 Land registry drawing (Plano catastro) EnSp.pdf
- C-0026b LOT B6 130219 Certification of property (Certificacion de propiedad) EnSp.pdf
- C-0026c LOT B6 051201 Decree of public interest (Decreto de interes publico) EnSp.pdf
- C-0026d LOT B6 060922 Administrative Appraisal (Avaluo Administrativo) EnSp.pdf
- C-0026d1 Lot B6 061115 Objection to Administrative Appraisal EnSp.pdf
- C-0026e LOT B6 061127 Decree of expropriation (Decreto de expropiacion) EnSp.pdf
- C-0026f LOT B6 061129 Initiation judicial proceedings (Interposicion Demanda) EnSp.pdf
- C-0026f1 LOT B6 080313 Act of Dispossession Sp.pdf
- C-0026f2 LOT B6 070826 First Judicial Appraisal (Primer Avaluo Judicial) EnSp.pdf
- C-0026g Lot B6 140730 Judgment (Sentencia) EnSp.pdf
- C-27 B7 Gremillion
- C-0027a LOT B7 130108 Land registry drawing (Plano catastro) EnSp.pdf
- C-0027b LOT B7 130219 Certification of property (Certificacion de propiedad) EnSp.pdf
- C-0027c LOT B7 051201 Decree of public interest (Decreto de interes publico) EnSp.pdf
- C-0027d LOT B7 060922 Administrative Appraisal (Avaluo Administrativo) EnSp.pdf
- C-0027d1 LOT B7 061117 Objection to Administrative Appraisal EnSp.pdf
- C-0027e LOT B7 061127 Decree of expropriation (Decreto de expropiacion) EnSp.pdf
- C-0027f LOT B7 061130 Initiation judicial proceedings (Interposicion Demanda) EnSp.pdf
- C-0027f1 LOT B7 080313 Act of Dispossession Sp.pdf
- C-0027f2 LOT B7 070215 First Judicial Appraisal (Primer avaluo Judicial) EnSp.pdf
- C-0027f3 LOT B7 091112 Second Judicial Appraisal (Segundo avaluo Judicial) EnSp.pdf
- C-0027g LOT B7 140919 Notification from Judge in advance of Judgment Sp.pdf
- C-0027g-1 LOT B7 150130 Judgment (Sentencia) Sp.pdf
- C-28 B8 Berkowitz
- C-0028a LOT B8 130108 Land registry drawing (Plano catastro) EnSp.pdf
- C-0028b LOT B8 130219 Certification of property (Certificacion de propiedad) EnSp.pdf
- C-0028c LOT B8 051201 Decree of public interest (Decreto de interes publico) EnSp.pdf
- C-0028d LOT B8 060922 Administrative Appraisal (Avaluo Administrativo) EnSp.pdf
- C-0028d1 Lot B8 061115 Obj. to the Adm Appraisal EnSp.pdf
- C-0028e LOT B8 061127 Decree of expropriation (Decreto de expropiacion) EnSp.pdf
- C-0028f LOT B8 061201 Initiation judicial proceedings (Interposicion Demanda) EnSp.pdf
- C-0028f1 LOT B8 080312 Act of Dispossession Sp.pdf
- C-0028f2 LOT B8 070412 First Judicial Appraisal EnSp.pdf
- C-0028f3 LOT B8 100308 Second Judicial Appraisal Sp.pdf
- C-0028g1 LOT B8 120531 Judgment (Sentencia) EnSp.pdf
- C-0028g2 LOT B8 120902 Judgment clarification (Sentencia aclaracion) EnSp.pdf
- C-0028g4 LOT B8 110902 First Judgment clarification and addition (Sentencia con aclaracion y adicion) EnSp.pdf
- C-0028h LOT B8 130513 130730 131203 131204 Appeal Documents EnSp.pdf
- C-0028i Lot B8 140730 Liquidation of costs (Liquidacion de costas)_EnSp.pdf
- C-0028j LOT B8 140806 Documents regarding interests Sp.pdf
- C-3 V30
- C-0003a LOT V30 130108 Land registry drawing (Plano catastro) EnSp.pdf
- C-0003b LOT V30 130219 Certification of property (Certificacion de propiedad) EnSp.pdf
- C-0003c LOT V30 071009 Decree of pubic interest (Decreto de interes publico) EnSp.pdf
- C-0003d LOT V30 080918 Administrative appraisal (Avaluo Administrativo) EnSp.pdf
- C-0003d1 LOT V30 090121 Objection to the Administrative Appraisal EnSp.pdf
- C-4 V31
- C-0004a LOT V31 130108 Land registry drawing (Plano catastro) EnSp.pdf
- C-0004b LOT V31 130219 Certification of property (Certificacion de propiedad) EnSp.pdf
- C-0004c LOT V31 071008 Decree of public interest (Decreto de interes publico) EnSp.pdf
- C-0004d LOT V31 080918 Administrative appraisal (Avaluo Administrativo) EnSp.pdf
- C-0004d1 LOT V31 090121 Objection to the Administrative Appraisal EnSp.pdf
- C-5 V32
- C-0005a LOT V32 130108 Land registry drawing (Plano catastro) EnSp.pdf
- C-0005b LOT V32 130219 Certification of property (Certificacion de propiedad) EnSp.pdf
- C-0005c1 LOT V32 071009 Decree of Public Interest (Decreto de Interes Publico) No33988 EnSp.pdf
- C-0005c2 LOT V32 071009 Decree of Public Interest 2 (Decreto de interes publico) No34002 EnSp.pdf
- C-0005d LOT V32 080918 Administrative appraisal (Avaluo Administrativo) EnSp.pdf
- C-0005d1 LOT V32 090121 Objection to the Administrative Appraisal EnSp.pdf
- C-6 V33
- C-0006a LOT V33 130108 Land registry drawing (Plano catastro) EnSp.pdf
- C-0006b LOT V33 130219 Certification of property (Certificacion de propiedad) EnSp.pdf
- C-0006c LOT V33 071009 Decree of public interest (Decreto de interes publico) EnSp.pdf
- C-0006d LOT V33 080918 Administrative appraisal (Avaluo Administrativo) EnSp.pdf
- C-0006d1 LOT V33 090402 Objection to the Administrative Appraisal EnSp.pdf
- C-7 V38 Copher
- C-0007a LOT V38 130108 Land registry drawing (Plano catastro) EnSp.pdf
- C-0007b LOT V38 130219 Certification of property (Certificacion de propiedad) EnSp.pdf
- C-0007c LOT V38 071009 Decree of Public Interest (Decreto de Interes Publico) EnSp.pdf
- C-0007d LOT V38 080917 Administrative Appraisal (Avaluo Administrativo) Sp.pdf
- C-0007d1 LOT V38 090121 Objection to the Administrative Appraisal Sp.pdf
- C-8 V39 Copher
- C-0008a LOT V39 130108 Land registry drawing (Plano catastro) EnSp.pdf
- C-0008b LOT V39 130219 Certification of property (Certificacion de propiedad) EnSp.pdf
- C-0008c LOT V39 071009 Decree of public interest (Decreto de interes publico) EnSp.pdf
- C-0008d LOT V39 080917 Administrative Appraisal (Avaluo Administrativo) EnSp.pdf
- C-0008d1 LOT V39 090121 Objection to Administrative Appraisal EnSp.pdf
- C-9 V40 Copher
- C-0009a LOT V40 130108 Land registry drawing (Plano catastro) EnSp.pdf
- C-0009b LOT V40 130219 Certification of property (Certificacion de propiedad) EnSp.pdf
- C-0009c LOT V40 071009 Decree of public interest ( Decreto de interes publico) EnSp.pdf
- C-0009d LOT V40 080918 Administrative Appraisal (Avaluo Administrativo) EnSp.pdf
- C-0009d1 LOT V40 090121 Objection to Administrative Appraisal EnSp.pdf
- C-0029 870526 Decree 17566 Refugio Nacional de Vida Silvestre Tamarindo Sp.pdf
- C-0030 Law 7149 creating the Refugio Nacional de Vida Silvestre Tamarindo (1990) EnSp.pdf
- C-0031 870903 Letter from Commissioner of the Wildlife Service (MINAE) EnSp.pdf
- C-0032 881103 Letter from Sea Turtle Rescue Program to MINAE EnSp.pdf
- C-0033 901211 Letter from Minister Bravo of MINAE to R. Medaglia Gomez EnSp.pdf
- C-0034 920617 Certification that Hotel Las Tortugas was not within the park EnSp.pdf
- C-0035 920000 Update Article Regarding the Creation of the Park EnSp.pdf
- C-0036 Property Tax Statements for Lots V30, V31, V32 and V33 Sp.pdf
- C-0037 Lots V38 - V40 SINAC Administrative Files Sp.pdf
- C-0038 Lots V46-V47 SINAC Administrative Files Sp.pdf
- C-0039 Lots V38 -V40 and V46-V47 Property tax values Sp.pdf
- C-0040 Development Plan for SPG Lots - Condiminio Montesol Sp.pdf
- C-0041 SPG Lots SETENA Correspondence EnSp.pdf
- C-0042 SPG Lots Development Costs En.pdf
- C-0043 New Playa Grande Zoning Regulations EnSp.pdf
- C-0044 Spence Co. Lots Property Tax Values Sp.pdf
- C-0045 Recent Requirements related to Piezometer Studies Sp.pdf
- C-0046 130612 Lot B7 Certification of Ownership EnSp.pdf
- C-0047 Lot B7 Purchase by Vacation Rentals, S.A. EnSp.pdf
- C-0048 Lot B7 041101 Architectural and 050606 Engineering Plans.pdf
- C-0049 111207 Letter from J. Demyen of ReMax En.pdf
- C-0050 Lot B7 Property Tax Value Sp.pdf
- C-0051 911216 920324 950420 Contemporaneous Correspondence from Ministry regarding the Park at its Creation EnSp.pdf
- C-0053 030716 Minutes from meeting between government agencies EnSp.pdf
- C-0054 REDACTED 030906 Lots B1 and B3 Public registration of transfer EnSp.pdf
- C-0055 REDACTED 030304 Lot B7 Purchase by Vacation Rentals EnSp.pdf
- C-0056 Panoramic Photos of B Lots from Playa Grande 1 of 3.jpg
- C-0056 Panoramic Photos of B Lots from Playa Grande 2 of 3.jpg
- C-0056 Panoramic Photos of B Lots from Playa Grande 3 of 3.jpg
- C-0056 Panoramic Photos of B Lots from Playa Grande.pdf
- C-0057 040621 Lt Dept de Geodesia to IGN explaining Lots B1, B3, B6, B7 properties outside Park EnSp.pdf
- C-0058 040621 Lots B1, B3, B6, B7 Lt MOPT to Admin Environment Tribunal properties outside Park EnSp.pdf
- C-0059 041105 Lot B5 Environmental Assessment Application Sp.pdf
- C-0060 041203 LOT B5 Lt SETENA and B. Berkowitz EnSp.pdf
- C-0061 051206 LOT B5 Payment by Pochote Mar Vista States SA to MINAE Sp.pdf
- C-0062 061205 Challenge to Decree of Public Interest EnSp.pdf
- C-0063 060322 Lots B3, B5, B6, and B8 Decision to Challenge Decrees of Public Interest Sp.pdf
- C-0064 KRW-1 140420 Kirt Rusenko Curriculum Vitae En.pdf
- C-0065 KRW-2 Voyage of the Turtle - Chapter 3, Moonlight in the Sunshine State En.pdf
- C-0066 KRW-3 080100 Evaluation of Sea Turtle Nesting in PG and Surrounding Area En.pdf
- C-0067 KRW-4 Edited Zoning Plan Playa Grande En.pdf
- C-0068 KRW-5 Forum of Experts Discuss Bill to Demote Leatherback National Park En.pdf
- C-0069 KRW-6 090715 Letter from MINAE to Kirt Rusenko with list of questions En.pdf
- C-0070 KRW-7 090827 Letter to MINAE attaching Kirt Rusenko's responses En.pdf
- C-0071 KRW-8 090625 Final Revision of Zoning Plan En.pdf
- C-0072 KRW-9 pictoral and graphic representations of the boundaries of the park Sp.pdf
- C-0073 KRW-10 exerpt from Leatherback Trust website En.PDF
- C-0074 050228 LT SETENA from MINAE EnSp.pdf
- C-0075 050310 LT SETENA from MINAE EnSp.pdf
- C-0076 KRW2 hyperlinked webpages En.pdf
- C-0077 KRW2 Exhibit A En.pdf
- C-0078 040000 Spotila and Paladino - Chapter on turtles En.pdf
- C-0079 030901 Denouncement of BB by Ranger Carlos Chang EnSp.pdf
- C-0080 031021 Mario Araya water approval LT ASADA EnSp.pdf
- C-0081 040531 Rotney Complaint TAA Reply EnSp.pdf
- C-0082 040611 Eduardo Madrigal Setena reply to TAA EnSp.pdf
- C-0083 041105 LF Dir of CR Natl Geo Inst EnSp.pdf
- C-0084 130500 Facio Geofisical-Geological and Hidrological study Sp.pdf
- C-0085 140700 Fostroy Estudio hidrogeológico y tránsito de contaminantes Sp.pdf
- C-0086 FPB12 140900 Hidrogeotecnia Report for B lots and SPG lots Sp.pdf
- C-0088 051024 excerpt transcript of Relatos del Viento EnSp.pdf
- C-0089 140930 LF Corredor En.pdf
- C-0090 000000 Photo of entrance to Las Baulas Park.jpg
- C-0091 140801 LF Mun de Santa Cruz Sobre Requisitos Permisos en Playa Grande SpEn.pdf
- C-0092 140500 Informe final plan accion baulas PARA ALCALDIA EnSp.pdf
- C-0092a 140505 MAPA GENERAL VOTO 18529-2008.pdf
- C-0092b 140507 TABLA GENERAL VOTO 18529-2008 PNM Las Baulas.xlsx
- C-0093 140731 LF Mun de Santa Cruz existencia de permisos de construccion Sp.pdf
- C-0094 140801 LF Mun de Santa Cruz existencia de permisos de construccion Sp.pdf
- C-0095 000000 Aide Memoire of the information contained in C-92.pdf
- C-0096 120224 SPG Lots Burn Permit Sp.pdf
- C-0097 070525 South Playa Grande Tree Permit Sp.pdf
- C-0098 060109 LOTS SPG1 and SPG2 Gov Exp Surveys Sp.pdf
- C-0099 940500 Lot V61 Catastro at time of purchase Sp.pdf
- C-0100 FPB1 see r-031 DIGH-038-09-SENARA Sp.pdf
- C-0101 FPB2 130400 Evaluación hidrogeológica, hidrogeoquimica e isotópica del acuifer Huacas-Tamarindo, SENARA Sp.pdf
- C-0102 FPB3 140129 AYA Memorando Subgerencia Gestion Sistemas Comunales Sp.pdf
- C-0103 FPB4 140930 Nota de la ASADA PG-Disponibilidad general de H2O Y OFICIO SGG-2014-1240 Sp.pdf
- C-0104 FPB5 060220 Executive decree 32967-MINAE Sp.pdf
- C-0105 FPB6 120612 SENARA, MINAE, AYA. Hydrogeology Methodologies to Analyze the Water Resource. Official Gazette n. 243 Sp.pdf
- C-0106 FPB7 130704 Hydrogeology Journal (Revista de Hidrogeología) - Foster, Hirata et al Sp.pdf
- C-0107 FPB8 140700 Official communication from the Costa Rican Professional Association of Geologists Sp.pdf
- C-0108 FPB9 140524 DIGH-143-14 SENARA Sp.PDF
- C-0110 FPB11 131216 Propuesta de modificación de la Matriz (SENARA, AYA, MINSAL, Colegios Profesionales) Sp.pdf
- C-0111 060116 (video) Sp.mpg
- C-0111 060116 (video) slip sheet.pdf
- C-0112a 080907 Nacion Art - Minae incapaz de comprar terrenos de parque Baulas EnSp.pdf
- C-0112b 080907 Nacion Art Estado tardará 75 años en pagar tierras de parques nacionales EnSp.pdf
- C-0112e 091116 La Nacion - Desconocimiento ministerial EnSp.pdf
- C-0115 120000 Piedra and Wallace Sea Turtles of the Eastern Pacific 2012 En.pdf
- C-0117 090717 The Tico Times - Bill Seeks Change in Status for BNMP En.pdf
- C-0120 090806 Playa Grande SA Land Study EnSp.pdf
- C-0121 080520 La Gaceta No. 96 - Law 16.915 to Protect the Baula Turtle in CR Sp.pdf
- C-0122 091203 La Nacion opinion J Rodriguez - Commitment Park Leatherback En.pdf
- C-0123 2009 2010 Various Press Releases En.pdf
- C-0124 141127 English translation of Exhibit R-097 En.pdf
- C-0127 REDACTED 030819 Lots V30-V34 Purchase Purchase En.pdf
- C-0129 REDACTED 040203 Lot V34 Sale En.pdf
- C-0134 REDACTED 070227 Lot V59 Purchase En.pdf
- C-0136 REDACTED 050204 Lot V61 Purchase En.pdf
- C-0138 REDACTED 051208 Lot V61 Sale En.pdf
- C-0139 REDACTED 080219 Lot V61 Reversion En.pdf
- C-0140 REDACTED 050127 Lot A40 Purchase En.pdf
- C-0142 REDACTED 050127 Lot A39 Purchase En.pdf
- C-0146 REDACTED 070607 Lot C71 Sale En.pdf
- C-0147 REDACTED 060331 Lots SPG1-SPG2 Purchase En.pdf
- C-0148 REDACTED 060405 Lots SPG1-SPG2 Title Policy En.pdf
- C-0149 REDACTED 060323 Lot SPG3 Purchase En.pdf
- C-0150 REDACTED 060329 Lot SPG3 Title Policy En.pdf
- C-0151 REDACTED 030116 Lots B1-B8 Purchase EnSp.pdf
- C-0152 REDACTED 030906 Lots B5-B8 Transfer EnSp.pdf
- C-0153 REDACTED 040120 Lot B2 Sale EnSp.pdf
- C-0154 REDACTED 040326 Lot B4 Sale EnSp.pdf
- C-0118 Negotiations 2008-2009
- Claimants' Expert Reports and Opinions
- 140425 FTI ER1 and Exhibits
- 140423 FTI Expert Report_Spence et al v Costa Rica _ 04 23 2014.pdf
- FTI 10_130110 Penelope Lent Letter re PG values.jpg
- FTI 10_130110 Penelope Lent Letter re PG values.pdf
- FTI 11_Dave Corredor Beachfront Listings.jpg
- FTI 11_Dave Corredor Beachfront Listings.pdf
- FTI 12 _131201 Hacienda Pinilla_Pricelist_Homesites.pdf
- FTI 13 PWC National Development Land Market 2nd Qtr 2008.pdf
- FTI 14__09172007_CostaRica.pdf
- FTI 15__Beach Front Lots - Avellanas - 17 November 08.pdf
- FTI 16 __Century 21 Comp. Sales.pdf
- FTI 17__document_sales data from P. Wheeler.pdf
- FTI 18__DP13Paus_CorderoApr08.pdf
- FTI 19 __estadisticas_2012.pdf
- FTI 1__110449-www2_AppraisalInstitute_TAJ1.03p75-93.pdf
- FTI 20 __industry-analysts-reveal-results-of-c.pdf
- FTI 21 __KayvonRoss Guanacaste Destination Management. Final Copy. 1.11.pdf
- FTI 22 __Las Catalinas Comps.pdf
- FTI 23 __Legal_and_Institutional_Framework_Related_to_Coastal_Tourism_Development.pdf
- FTI 24 __NY Times 2.3.2006.pdf
- FTI 25 __NY Times 12.18.2013.pdf
- FTI 26__Statistical_Yearly_Tourism Report_2012.pdf
- FTI 27___Summary_Report_-_Impact_Tourism_Related_Development_Pacific_Coast_Costa_Rica.pdf
- FTI 28 __www-remax-oceansurf-cr-com.pdf
- FTI 29_ ReMax Gold Coast re B7.pdf
- FTI 2__110449-www2_webpac-bin_pdf_taj2008_TAJSp08Pg.155-167.pdf
- FTI 30_041101 Gremillion Residence and Guest Houses - Plans.pdf
- FTI 32_B.30 080231 Assignment Wakeup Call to GBH (V61)Buy back En.pdf
- FTI 35_OK to build on Lots 39 and 40.pdf
- FTI 36_SPG 1 2 3 Subdivision Lot Yield A.JPG
- FTI 36_SPG 1 2 3 Subdivision Lot Yield A.pdf
- FTI 37_SPG 1 2 3 Subdivision Lot Yield B.JPG
- FTI 37_SPG 1 2 3 Subdivision Lot Yield B.pdf
- FTI 38_Zoning_Lots B1 to B8.pdf
- FTI 39_Hacienda Pinilla Avellanas Parcel Map.jpg
- FTI 39_Hacienda Pinilla Avellanas Parcel Map.pdf
- FTI 3_2012 Analysis_of_the_Daniel_Oduber_Quirós_International_Airport_Liberia_Guanacaste (1).pdf
- FTI 4_ Partial Taking Expropriation The Remainder.pdf
- FTI 5_120110 Pennye Wheeler PG Values.pdf
- FTI 6_130108 Bob Davey beach front properties report July 2008.xls
- FTI 7_130108 Bob Davey PG Values.pdf
- FTI 8_130110 Dave Corredor Beachfront Values p1.jpg
- FTI 8_130110 Dave Corredor Beachfront Values p1.pdf
- FTI 9_130110 Dave Corredor Beachfront Values p2.jpg
- FTI 9_130110 Dave Corredor Beachfront Values p2.pdf
- 141002 FTI Reply Report_Spence et al v Costa Rica.pdf
- 141002_Peralta_ER1.pdf
- 141002_Ruiz_ER1.pdf
- 150203 Mendelson Expert Opinion - Appendix 1 CV En.PDF
- 150203 Mendelson Expert Opinion En.pdf
- 140425 FTI ER1 and Exhibits
- Claimants' Witness Statements
- Hearing on Jurisdiction and Merits 20-24 April 2015
- April 20, 2015
- April 24, 2015
- Transcripts
- Hearing on Merits - Transcript - Day 001 - English - condensed.pdf
- Hearing on Merits - Transcript - Day 001 - Spanish (002).pdf
- Hearing on Merits - Transcript - Day 002 - English - condensed.pdf
- Hearing on Merits - Transcript - Day 002 - Spanish.pdf
- Hearing on Merits - Transcript - Day 003 - English - condensed.pdf
- Hearing on Merits - Transcript - Day 003 - Spanish.pdf
- Hearing on Merits - Transcript - Day 004 - English - condensed.pdf
- Hearing on Merits - Transcript - Day 004 - Spanish.pdf
- Hearing on Merits - Transcript - Day 005 - English - condensed.pdf
- Hearing on Merits - Transcript - Day 005 - Spanish.pdf
- Lot Updates of 11 August 2015
- C-0024b-bis Lot B3 150409 Updated Certification of Property En.pdf
- C-0024b-bis Lot B3 150409 Updated Certification of Property.pdf
- C-0028b-bis Lot B8 150409 Updated Certification of Property.En.pdf
- C-0028b-bis Lot B8 150409 Updated Certification of Property.pdf
- R-171 - 150505 Lot B6 Decision of the Administrative and Civil Court.en.pdf
- R-171 - 150505 Lot B6 Decision of the Administrative and Civil Court.pdf
- R-172 - 150611 Lot B6 National Registry Update. en.pdf
- R-172 - 150611 Lot B6 National Registry Update.pdf
- R-173 - 150604 Lot B5 Decision of the Administrative and Civil Court. en.pdf
- R-173 - 150604 Lot B5 Decision of the Administrative and Civil Court.pdf
- Lot Updates of 5 February 2016
- R-188 National Registry Update Indicating that the Property Was Transferred to the State Lot B5.pdf
- R-189 Appeal Judgment Affirming Court of First Instance Decision Lot B7.pdf
- R-190Notification of Deposit of Difference Between Administrative Valuation and Final Decision of Court of Appeal Lot B7.pdf
- R-191 Annulment of Decision of Legal Interest Lot B8.pdf
- R-193 National Registry Update Indicating that the Property Was Transferred to the State Lot SPG2.pdf
- R192 Decision to Lift Suspension Nullify Decision and Remand Same for Court 1st Instance to Issue a New Judgment-Lot SPG1.pdf
- Lot Updates of 6 July 2016
- C-0016j1 Lot A40 150211 Resolution Regarding Interest and 20 March 2015 Receipts.pdf
- C-0023g Lot B1 160104 Resolution Regarding Suspension of Proceedings.pdf
- C-0024j1 Lot B3 150320 Resolution regarding interest EnSp.pdf
- C-0024j2 Lot B3 160523 Report Generated by the Court Indicating the Date of Deposit of Funds by the State.pdf
- C-0025g Lot B5 150311 Judgment confirming administrative appraisal EnSp.pdf
- C-0027g2 Lot B7 150302 Resolution Regarding Correction of Errors and Admitting Appeal of the State.pdf
- C-0027i Lot B7 160121 Resolution ordering payment of principal EnSp.pdf
- C-0027j2 Lot B7 Report Generated by the Court Indicating the Date of Deposit of Funds by the State.pdf
- C-0028i Lot B8-22 January 2016 Resolution Ordering the Payment of the Administrative Appraisal.pdf
- R-194 160408 Lot B3 Document evidencing deposit made EnSp.pdf
- R-195 160211 Document evidencing payment of principal EnSp.pdf
- R-196 (C-0027j1) Lot B7 160504 JJudgment Fixing Amount of Interest and Legal Fees Due to Owner of Lot B7.pdf
- Parties’ answers to the questions posed by the Tribunal on November 25, 2015 (December 23, 2015)
- Clamaints
- Respondent
- Respondent's Factual Exhibits
- R-001.PDF
- R-002.PDF
- R-003.PDF
- R-004.PDF
- R-005.PDF
- R-006.PDF
- R-007.PDF
- R-008.PDF
- R-009.PDF
- R-010.PDF
- R-011.PDF
- R-012.PDF
- R-013.PDF
- R-014.PDF
- R-015.PDF
- R-016.PDF
- R-017.PDF
- R-018.PDF
- R-019.PDF
- R-020.PDF
- R-021.PDF
- R-022.PDF
- R-023.PDF
- R-024.PDF
- R-025.PDF
- R-026.PDF
- R-027.PDF
- R-028.PDF
- R-029.PDF
- R-030.PDF
- R-031.PDF
- R-032.PDF
- R-033.PDF
- R-034.PDF
- R-035.PDF
- R-036.PDF
- R-037.PDF
- R-038.PDF
- R-039.PDF
- R-040.PDF
- R-041.PDF
- R-042.PDF
- R-043.PDF
- R-044.PDF
- R-045.PDF
- R-046.PDF
- R-047.PDF
- R-048.PDF
- R-049.PDF
- R-050.PDF
- R-051.PDF
- R-052.PDF
- R-053.PDF
- R-054.PDF
- R-055.PDF
- R-056.PDF
- R-057.PDF
- R-058.PDF
- R-059.PDF
- R-060.PDF
- R-061.PDF
- R-062.PDF
- R-063.PDF
- R-064.PDF
- R-065.PDF
- R-066.PDF
- R-067.PDF
- R-068.PDF
- R-069.PDF
- R-070.PDF
- R-071.PDF
- R-072.PDF
- R-073.PDF
- R-074.PDF
- R-075.PDF
- R-076.PDF
- R-077.PDF
- R-078.PDF
- R-079.PDF
- R-080.PDF
- R-081.PDF
- R-082.PDF
- R-083.PDF
- R-155 .pdf
- R-174 (Redacted).pdf
- R-176 (Redacted).pdf
- R-177 (Redacted).pdf
- R-178 (Redacted).pdf
- R-181(Redacted).pdf
- R-185 (Redacted).pdf
- r-084.pdf
- r-085.pdf
- r-086.pdf
- r-087.pdf
- r-088.pdf
- r-089.pdf
- r-090.pdf
- r-091.pdf
- r-092.pdf
- r-093.pdf
- r-094.pdf
- r-095.pdf
- r-096.pdf
- r-097.pdf
- r-098.pdf
- r-099.pdf
- r-100.pdf
- r-101.pdf
- r-102.pdf
- r-103.pdf
- r-104.pdf
- r-105.pdf
- r-106.pdf
- r-107.pdf
- r-108.pdf
- r-109.pdf
- r-110.pdf
- r-111.pdf
- r-112.pdf
- r-113.pdf
- r-114.pdf
- r-115.pdf
- r-116.pdf
- r-117.pdf
- r-118.pdf
- r-119.pdf
- r-120.pdf
- r-121.pdf
- r-122.pdf
- r-123.pdf
- r-124.pdf
- r-125.pdf
- r-126.pdf
- r-127.pdf
- r-128.pdf
- r-129.pdf
- r-130.pdf
- r-131.pdf
- r-132.pdf
- r-133.pdf
- r-134.pdf
- r-135.pdf
- r-136.pdf
- r-137.pdf
- r-138.pdf
- r-139.pdf
- r-140.pdf
- r-141.pdf
- r-142.pdf
- r-143.pdf
- r-144.pdf
- r-145.pdf
- r-146.pdf
- r-147.pdf
- r-148.pdf
- r-149.pdf
- r-150.pdf
- r-151.pdf
- r-152.pdf
- r-153.pdf
- r-154.pdf
- r-156.pdf
- r-157.pdf
- r-158.pdf
- r-159.pdf
- r-160.pdf
- r-161.pdf
- r-162.pdf
- r-163.pdf
- r-164.pdf
- r-165.pdf
- r-166.pdf
- r-167.pdf
- r-168.pdf
- r-169.pdf
- r-170.pdf
- Respondent's Witness Statements and Expert Report
- RWE-001 (Solano) ENG.pdf
- RWE-001 (Solano).pdf
- RWE-002 (Piedra) ENG.pdf
- RWE-002 (Piedra).pdf
- RWE-003 (Loáiciga) ENG.pdf
- RWE-003 (Loáiciga).pdf
- RWE-004 (Kaczmarek - with appendices).pdf
- RWE-005 (Agudelo) ENG.pdf
- RWE-005 (Agudelo).pdf
- RWE-006 (Jurado) ENG.pdf
- RWE-006 (Jurado).pdf
- RWE-007 (Solano) ENG.pdf
- RWE-007 (Solano).pdf
- RWE-008 (Piedra) ENG.pdf
- RWE-008 (Piedra).pdf
- RWE-009 (Loaiciga) ENG.pdf
- RWE-009 (Loaiciga).pdf
- RWE-010 (Chaves) ENG.pdf
- RWE-010 (Chaves).pdf
- RWE-011 (Kaczmarek - with appendices).pdf
- RWE-012 (Milano) ENG.pdf
- RWE-012 (Milano).pdf
- RWE-013 (Schwebel).pdf
